Reputation
Badges, awards and polished content can signal credibility. But trust depends on evidence, experience and consistency—and on whether what we say survives contact with what we do.
Jorge A. Vergara Sánchez
7 min

You can buy the signal. But can you buy what it's supposed to represent?
Lately, I’ve been seeing ads on social media making an interesting promise.
Subscribe. Get verified. Stand out. Build credibility.
And every time I see one, I keep coming back to the same question:
Are trust and credibility for sale now?
And if they are:
Who exactly is buying them?
I don’t mean only who is paying for the subscription, I mean something more important.
Who is actually believing it?
Because those are two very different transactions.
We have always looked for signals of credibility
This isn't entirely new.
We rarely have all the information we need to determine whether a person, company or institution deserves our trust.
So we use shortcuts.
A respected university.
A senior job title.
A recognizable company.
An industry certification.
An award.
A recommendation.
Media coverage.
A professional association.
A verified account.
These things help us answer a very human question:
“Should I believe this person or organization?”
And many of those signals are perfectly legitimate. The problem begins when we confuse the signal of credibility with credibility itself.
Because increasingly, some of those signals can be purchased.
You can buy the signal
Let's be clear.
Companies have always spent money on things that can strengthen their credibility.
PR agencies.
Advertising.
Memberships.
Sponsorships.
Certifications.
Awards programs.
Analyst relations.
Executive positioning.
Branded content.
Premium digital features.
There is nothing inherently wrong with any of them.
Some provide meaningful validation, increase visibility, create access, and some help organizations communicate genuine expertise more effectively.
But there's an important distinction:
You can buy the signal. That doesn't necessarily mean you bought what the signal is supposed to represent.
You can buy visibility.
You can buy reach.
You can buy a premium profile.
You can buy a beautifully produced thought-leadership campaign.
You can pay to enter an awards program.
You can pay for a certification process.
You can certainly buy a very impressive corporate website.
But can you buy trust?
Looking credible has never been easier
This question becomes even more relevant because technology has dramatically reduced the cost of appearing sophisticated.
Anyone can now create a polished website, professional-looking photography, a compelling executive biography, beautiful presentations, well-written articles, high-quality video, and, with generative AI, seemingly authoritative content on practically any subject.
That's an extraordinary democratization of capability. But it also creates a new reputational challenge.
Many of the superficial cues we once associated with expertise are becoming easier and cheaper to reproduce.
Professional-looking no longer necessarily means professional.
Polished doesn't necessarily mean knowledgeable.
Visible doesn't necessarily mean relevant.
Verified doesn't necessarily mean trustworthy.
Which raises another question:
If everyone can look credible, how will we decide who actually is?
Credibility has to survive contact with reality
This is where I believe Corporate Communications has an important role. Credibility isn't simply something we declare, it develops through a sequence.
CLAIM → PROOF → EXPERIENCE → CONSISTENCY → CREDIBILITY
We make a claim.
“We put our customers first.”
“We are innovative.”
“We care about our people.”
“We are a responsible company.”
“We are experts in this field.”
Then comes proof.
What evidence supports that claim?
Then experience.
What happens when a customer actually interacts with us?
What does an employee experience inside the organization?
What happens when a journalist asks a difficult question?
How do we behave when something goes wrong?
Then comes consistency.
Does the experience support the claim once?
Or repeatedly?
Because credibility doesn't come from saying the right thing once.
It accumulates when what we say and what people experience align consistently enough that they begin to believe us the next time.
That is much harder to buy.
Communications can't manufacture credibility
Our profession needs to be particularly careful here. Corporate Communications works with credibility signals all the time.
Awards.
Rankings.
Speaking opportunities.
Executive visibility.
Media coverage.
Thought leadership.
Third-party endorsements.
Certifications.
Partnerships.
Research.
We use them because third-party validation can be extremely powerful, but perhaps we should ask ourselves more frequently:
Are we using these things as evidence of something real — or as substitutes for it?
There is a meaningful difference.
An award can reinforce credibility when it recognizes genuine performance.
Media coverage can strengthen credibility when independent scrutiny supports the story.
A certification can provide meaningful assurance when the standards behind it are rigorous.
Executive thought leadership can build authority when there is actual expertise behind the executive.
But none of them should become a shortcut around substance.
Because eventually someone will experience the organization behind the signal, and that's where the test begins.
Who is buying it?
This brings me back to the question that interests me most.
If credibility can increasingly be packaged, promoted and sold:
Who is buying it?
Customers?
Employees?
Candidates?
Investors?
Journalists?
Business partners?
Maybe.
But probably not all in the same way.
Different stakeholders have different reasons to trust us — and different ways of testing whether that trust is deserved.
A candidate might compare our employer-brand messaging with what employees say about us.
A customer might compare our promise with the experience of using our product.
A journalist might compare an executive statement with the company's previous behavior.
An investor might compare our narrative with our performance.
An employee might compare our stated values with what their manager does every day.
And this is where reputation becomes much more difficult to manipulate than an image.
People compare.
They connect signals, they notice inconsistencies.
And when the claim and the experience repeatedly contradict each other, eventually the credibility signal stops working.
And now machines are part of the audience
There is another dimension we're only beginning to understand. Increasingly, people aren't discovering companies, products or experts directly.
They're asking AI.
Which means humans may no longer be the only ones evaluating the information ecosystem around our organizations.
AI systems encounter company websites, media coverage, third-party references, executive content, research, reviews, public information and other signals of authority.
That introduces a fascinating new question for Corporate Communications:
What does credibility look like when both people and machines are deciding whom to believe?
I don't think we have the complete answer yet.
But I suspect consistency will matter even more.
Because one polished piece of content becomes less persuasive when it sits inside an ecosystem of contradictory information.
Maybe we need a credibility test
Before using a badge, award, ranking, certification, subscription, endorsement or any other credibility signal, perhaps communicators should ask a few basic questions:
What exactly are we claiming?
What proves it?
Who besides us says it's true?
Does the stakeholder experience support it?
Would we be comfortable if someone scrutinized the claim?
And perhaps the most revealing one:
Would this still be credible if we removed the badge?
If the entire proposition collapses when the symbol of credibility disappears, maybe the problem isn't the symbol, maybe there wasn't enough underneath it.
Trust and credibility aren't exactly the same thing
There's also a distinction worth making.
Credibility helps me believe what you say.
Trust helps me believe what you will do.
One can contribute to the other, but neither is created by a single signal.
Credibility can be strengthened by expertise, evidence and consistency.
Trust requires something more: experience over time.
It involves expectations.
If I trust an organization, I'm making a bet about its future behavior based partly on what I've seen it do before. Which is why trust can take years to build and remarkably little time to damage.
No subscription can bypass that process.
[ THE REBEL TAKE ]
We have never had more ways to look credible.
Badges.
Awards.
Rankings.
Followers.
Certifications.
Premium accounts.
Professional content.
Executive visibility.
AI-generated expertise.
Some are valuable.
Some are meaningful.
Some genuinely help us decide whom to trust.
But perhaps we need to become much better at distinguishing:
evidence of credibility from the appearance of credibility.
Visibility can be bought.
Reach can be bought.
Authority can be signaled.
Recognition can sometimes be paid for.
Trust is different.
Trust exists when what you say survives contact with what you do.
And credibility accumulates when that happens consistently enough for people to believe you the next time.
So perhaps the question isn't only:
Are trust and credibility for sale?
Maybe we should also be asking:
Who is buying it?
And, more importantly:
What happens when they discover what they bought?
READ THE ROOM.